|
EDITORIAL
Hans Larsen |
Findings from LAFS II – Part 2
Triggers
* cheese, spicy foods, rice, chocolate, sugar, wheat, MSG
Effect of Interventions
A. Radiofrequency Ablation
Three vagal afibbers underwent ablation for atrial flutter; they also had atrial fibrillation so an
attempt was made to eliminate the fibrillation foci at the same time. The flutter ablations were
successful in all cases. One of the fibrillation ablations, done at the Virginia Mason Hospital in
Seattle (Dr. Chris Fellow), was successful but the patient is still taking beta-blockers to prevent
further afib episodes. The remaining two afib ablations were not successful and the patients are
still taking antiarrhythmics to prevent episodes. These last two procedures were done at the
Seton Medical Center in Austin and the Ottawa Heart Institute in Canada.
Two of the procedures involving vagal afibbers were done within the last six months. One, done
at Johns Hopkins (Dr. Calkins), appears to have been at least partly successful although the
patient is still on Tambocor. The other has, so far, not been successful and the patient is still on
antiarrhythmics.
No adrenergic afibbers reported ablation therapy. It is not clear whether this is because they did
not attempt it or because the electrophysiologist could not find an active area to ablate.
Five afibbers with the mixed variety of LAF underwent ablation. Two of these operations were
clearly not successful; one was performed at Saint Joseph's Hospital in Tampa, and one at St.
Thomas Hospital in London, England. It is too early to tell whether the remaining three were
successful, but a least one, done at the Cleveland Clinic (Dr. Natale) appears to have been.
Two chronic afibbers had ablation therapy. One operation, done at the Duke Medical Center (Dr.
Marcus Wharton), was successful. The other was done very recently and it is not clear whether it
was successful or not.
In conclusion, four of the 15 ablation surgeries reported were completely successful and the
patients are off all antiarrhythmics. One procedure was successful, but the patient is still on beta-
blockers. Four operations were clearly not successful, and six were done so recently that it is
difficult to say whether they were successful. It is not clear whether the lack of success with
ablation for atrial fibrillation was due to poor procedure or because there was nothing to ablate
(no focal points).
B. Maze Procedure
C. Amalgam Replacement
Nevertheless, there does not appear to be any significant amalgam-related difference in number
and severity of episodes as far as adrenergic and mixed afibbers are concerned. There is,
however, an indication that vagal afibbers with amalgam fillings have more episodes (median of 4
versus 2 per 6 months) and spend more time in fibrillation per month (median of 5 hours versus
1.7 hours for those without amalgams). This possible effect needs to be confirmed in a detailed
correlation analysis.
A total of 10 people (6 vagal, 3 mixed, 1 adrenergic) with paroxysmal LAF have had their
amalgam fillings replaced. Five of them underwent proper detoxification while four did not. The
detoxification status of the remaining person is unknown. Detoxification did not seem to affect the
number of episodes, but it did affect their duration. The average time spent in fibrillation for the
detox group was 3 hours per month versus 21 hours for those who had not detoxified.
Considerable caution is needed though in interpreting these numbers since the sample size is
very small.
Subjectively, some people felt that amalgam removal had been highly beneficial whilst others had
observed no benefits. Here are their comments:
So, it's a fairly mixed bag of results. Amalgam replacement and detoxification would likely have
overall health benefits including a reduction in the risk of developing neurodegenerative diseases
such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's. However, it is not clear that it should be the first measure
taken against lone atrial fibrillation unless you have proven toxic levels of mercury in your body
and/or are especially sensitive to mercury. In any case, amalgam replacement should always be
performed under strictly controlled conditions and followed up by thorough detoxification. See the
July 2001 issue of The AFIB Report for more details.
D. Anti-inflammation Protocol
I would conclude that the anti-inflammation protocol (published in the September 2001 issue of
The AFIB Report) is worth a try if a C-reactive protein (CRP) test shows a higher than normal
value indicating the presence of an inflammation.
That's all for now. In the next issue we will begin the evaluation of the effectiveness of
antiarrhythmic drugs in the prevention of LAF episodes.
|
Is LAF Really Idiopathic?It is becoming increasingly clear that calling atrial fibrillation with no underlying heart disease "idiopathic", i.e. of no known cause, is no longer appropriate. Recent research has uncovered at least three conditions that can initiate and promote atrial fibrillation in people free of heart disease. Inflammation, oxidative stress, and a dysfunctional autonomic nervous system (ANS) have all been found to be potential causes of atrial fibrillation (AF). Emotional stress has also been linked to the initiation of AF, but may act through its effect on the autonomic nervous system (heightened adrenergic tone), the immune system (inflammation) or by creating additional oxidative stress. AF and Oxidative Stress The role of oxidative stress was discussed in the March 2002 issue of The AFIB Report. I have since come across two articles that further support the idea that oxidative stress is involved in atrial fibrillation. Researchers at the Cleveland Clinic and the Ohio State University have found that AF patients show signs of extensive oxidative injury to their myofibrillar creatine kinase (MM- CK). MM-CK controls the contraction of individual heart cells (myocytes). The researchers also determined that the oxidative damage was caused by peroxynitrite, a highly potent free radical. They conclude that peroxynitrite-induced oxidative stress can damage individual heart cells to such an extent that their normal function is disrupted and atrial fibrillation results[1]. The Cleveland Clinic researchers later followed up these initial findings by an experiment designed to show whether reducing the level of peroxynitrite through the use of an antioxidant (vitamin C) would prevent surgery-induced atrial fibrillation. Their clinical trial involved 50 bypass surgery patients who were given 2 grams of ascorbic acid (extended release) the night before surgery, followed by 500 mg doses twice daily for 5 days after surgery. The incidence of postoperative AF in the vitamin C group was 16.3% as compared to 34.9% in a comparable group not given vitamin C. The researchers conclude that AF episodes are sustained by oxidative stress and increased peroxynitrite generation caused by the rapid heart rate[2]. The conclusion is clear, oxidative stress is involved in both the initiation and maintenance of AF and supplementation with vitamin C, a potent antioxidant, helps prevent AF. I personally believe that gamma-tocopherol and lycopene are as effective, if not more effective than vitamin C, in neutralizing peroxynitrite radicals. Gamma-tocopherol and lycopene are both fat-soluble antioxidants found in the membranes of cells whereas vitamin C is water-soluble and found in the watery part of the cell. For optimum prevention of AF a combination of the 3 antioxidants is required. Inflammation The role of inflammation was discussed in the September 2001 issue of The AFIB Report. The idea that an inflammation of the heart lining can cause AF has since been supported by work done at the Cleveland Clinic and the University of Athens (The AFIB Report, February 2002). Both groups of researchers found a clear association between the level of C-reactive protein (CRP), a marker for inflammation, and the presence and severity of lone atrial fibrillation[3,4]. The junctions of the pulmonary veins and the left atrium are prime sites for the initiation of LAF. Creating a physical barrier between these sites (foci) and the rest of the heart via radiofrequency or ultrasound ablation is now accepted as a highly effective means of preventing LAF[5]. The origin of the offending foci is not known, but it seems plausible that they could be sites of local inflammation. Systemic inflammation can be successfully controlled with prednisone. This drug, however, has many serious adverse effects and is not recommended for extended use. There are also several natural supplements (The AFIB Report, September 2001) that are quite effective in combating inflammation. Giving them a try is worthwhile if an inflammation (high CRP level) is present. Autonomic Nervous System Dysfunction The heart begins beating on its own in the early embryonic stage and continues to do so until death. The nervous system develops at a later stage and extends its control to the heart primarily through its connection with the sinoatrial node. Both sympathetic (adrenergic) and parasympathetic (vagal, cholinergic) nerves are involved in heart rate control. It must be emphasized that the heart is perfectly capable of beating on its own without any help from the ANS. Transplanted hearts have no ANS connection and yet keep beating just fine. The autonomic nervous system basically serves as an override-control mechanism that helps the heart and circulatory system adjust to changes in the external or internal environment. A classic example of this is the fight or flight reaction where a whole cascade of body changes, including an accelerated heart rate, is "ordered" by the ANS to meet an actual or perceived threat. The main body functions controlled by the ANS are vision (pupil dilation), breathing, heart rate, skin temperature, and digestion. The ANS is basically a two-way communication system with the control centers for the different organs (pupils, lungs, heart, blood vessels, digestive tract and liver) both receiving input from and sending instructions to the individual organs. The nerve fibres transmitting information about the status of an organ to its control center are called afferent fibres whilst those that transmit instructions for actions are called efferent. The two types often run alongside each other and both terminate in the control centers. Maintaining a blood pressure sufficient to ensure an adequate blood supply throughout the body but low enough to avoid bursting small capillaries in the brain is perhaps one of the most important tasks of the ANS. The cardiac control center of the ANS constantly receives input from baroreceptors. These specialized muscle fibres are located in the walls of the heart and the major arteries and they "measure" the blood pressure by stretching and relaxing as the blood flows past them. A lower than desired pressure will cause the ANS to activate the sympathetic nervous system and thus make the heart beat faster and the blood vessels constrict whilst too high a pressure will activate the parasympathetic system slowing down the heart and dilating the blood vessels. The override mechanism of the ANS usually functions flawlessly and most people are not aware that it even takes place. However, if the adrenergic and vagal inputs to the heart become unbalanced atrial fibrillation can result. There is ample evidence that AF episodes are preceded by an abnormally high level of either adrenergic (sympathetic) or vagal (parasympathetic) activity[6,7]. It is not clear though whether these disturbances cause AF on their own or whether an inflammation or excessive oxidative stress is also required in order to initiate and sustain AF. Sorting out the relative "contributions" of inflammation, oxidative stress and ANS dysfunction to atrial fibrillation is actually quite difficult. Oxidative stress and inflammation are closely linked as is inflammation and ANS dysfunction. Nevertheless, it may prove fruitful to take a closer look at the ANS/heart connection. The heart muscle itself and the sinoatrial node, in particular, are supplied by both sympathetic and parasympathetic postganglionic nerve fibres. The sympathetic (adrenergic) speeds up the heart beat whilst the parasympathetic (vagal, cholinergic) fibres slow it down. The sympathetic nerve fibres originate in the spinal cord whilst the parasympathetic fibres originate in the brain stem (medulla oblongata) as the 10th cranial or vagus nerve. Some very recent research has shown that the actual control center for the heart is located in the medulla oblongata right in the area where the vagus nerve terminal is located[8]. This finding may have far reaching consequences and may provide an important clue as to the origin of the ANS dysfunction that helps precipitate AF. The Digestion Connection The digestive system, from initial saliva generation, through the generation of digestive enzymes and gastric juice, nutrient absorption in the small intestine, and final defecation, is controlled by the vagus nerve with minor input from the sympathetic branch of the ANS. Could disturbances in the digestive system somehow translate into heart rhythm problems through the common factor of the vagus nerve? Recent research would indicate that there could indeed be a connection. Argentine researchers have discovered a strong association between the presence of diverticular disease (diverticulosis) of the colon and vagal atrial fibrillation. They performed barium enema examinations on 16 patients under the age of 50 years with documented vagal AF and found that 14 (87.5%) of them had diverticulosis. This compares to an incidence of 5% among the general population. The researchers conclude that there is a strong association between vagal AF and diverticular disease of the colon[9]. I asked Dr. Vladimir Shusterman, a member of the team which discovered the exact location of the "cardiac control center", the question, "Could your finding, that the "cardiac control center" is located very close to the vagus nerve, explain the recently discovered association between diverticular disease of the colon and vagal atrial fibrillation? In other words, is it possible that digestive problems could cause feedback that would activate the stimulation point you discovered and thus cause heart rhythm irregularities?" Dr. Shusterman replied, "The idea that intestinal problems can lead to the activation of vagus, which, in turn, would activate a cascade of central responses perturbing cardiac rhythm makes a lot of sense"[10]. The possibility that digestive tract problems can cause ANS disturbances ultimately leading to atrial fibrillation is indeed an intriguing one and opens up a whole new perspective on the prevention of LAF. Many afibbers, particularly those with the vagal variety, have episodes shortly after eating their evening meal. It is as if the mere mobilization of the digestive system is enough to "irritate" the vagus nerve to such an extent that the feedback causes the heart rhythm to become irregular. Some vagal afibbers have found that taking pancreatic enzymes before dinner helps in avoiding this type of episode. The body's own production of pancreatic enzymes is entirely controlled by the vagus nerve. This means that if more enzymes are called for a more active vagal response is required. The effect of this higher vagal tone probably extends to the heart and could conceivably result in the initiation of a vagal episode. Supplementing with pancreatic enzymes would reduce the need of the pancreas to produce them and might therefore reduce vagal tone. Add to this the proven anti-inflammatory effects of pancreatic enzymes and it is clear that they could be a very important supplement for lone afibbers. Cotazym and Zypan are two effective pancreatic enzyme preparations. Another good remedy for an "over-excitable" digestive system is peppermint oil. This essential oil seems to calm the intestines and prevent spasms in the colon. It needs to be taken in the form of enteric-coated capsules in order to reach the intestines intact. I have found that taking 2 capsules about an hour before dinner is very effective. Quite apart from diverticular disease there is a whole raft of digestive system disorders, which are associated with an ANS disturbance either directly or through the intermediary of an inflammation or the formation of excessive amounts of free radical (oxidative stress).
Food sensitivities and allergies
Indigestion (dyspepsia)
Gastritis
GERD (gastroesophageal reflux disease)
Irritable bowel syndrome
Inflammatory bowel diseases (Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis) Conclusion There is substantial evidence that digestive disorders are associated not only with inflammation and oxidative stress, but also with autonomic system dysfunction. It is plausible that the ANS dysfunction could be a factor in initiating AF episodes. In future issues we will take a look at how digestive disorders can be effectively managed and will also devote considerable space to exploring the connection between LAF and emotional stress. I believe that it will ultimately be possible to reduce the frequency of LAF episodes by avoiding the triggers, eliminating inflammation, excessive emotional stress and oxidative stress, and by paying close attention to the digestive connection. It is clear that the heart "remembers" episodes and that the more frequent they are the more likely it is that another one will occur. Professor Michael Rosen, MD at Columbia University recently discovered that the heart remembers arrhythmias for at least a month and is more prone to go into arrhythmia for as long as the memory lasts[32]. So the goal should be to avoid episodes for one or, even better, two months so as to completely erase the memory of the last episode. Nevertheless, I do believe that "eternal vigilance" is going to be required to remain afib-free.
References
|
AFIB News
AF linked to colon disorder
Magnesium depletion linked to chronic stress
Rate control best for chronic afibbers
Pulmonary vein isolation is safe and effective
|
The AFIB REPORT is published monthly by Hans R. Larsen MSc ChE 1320 Point Street Victoria, BC, Canada V8S 1A5 Phone: (250) 384-2524 E-mail: [email protected] URL: http://www.afibbers.org Copyright © 2002 by Hans R. Larsen The AFIB REPORT does not provide medical advice. Do not attempt self- diagnosis or self-medication based on our reports. Please consult your health-care provider if you wish to follow up on the information presented. |