|
![]() |
![]() |
EDITORIAL
Hans Larsen |
Magnesium/Bicarbonate (Waller) Water TrialMagnesium-rich mineral waters are easily absorbed and have many health benefits due not only to their magnesium content, but also because of their content of bicarbonate ions that help neutralize the carbonic acid formed in the body during metabolic processes. Erling Waller, a former afibber, and Jackie Burgess, both frequent contributors to the Bulletin Board, collaborated to develop a recipe for homemade magnesium/bicarbonate water. The recipe is based on the reaction of magnesium hydroxide (in milk of magnesia) with plain carbonated water according to the formula Mg(OH)2 + 2CO2 --> Mg(HCO3)2. The magnesium/bicarbonate (Waller) water contains approximately 125 mg of elemental magnesium and 625 mg of bicarbonate per liter and has a pH of 8+. A small trial was undertaken in October 2002 to determine whether consuming the water had a noticeable effect on the frequency or duration of LAF episodes and whether there were any significant side effects from consuming the water. Fifteen afibbers participated in the trial (13 men and 2 women). The group consisted of 2 adrenergic, 6 mixed, and 7 vagal afibbers. The average age of the group was 59 years with a range of 44 to 73 years. Average age at diagnosis was 51 years with a range of 18 to 68 years. Twenty-one per cent (3 participants) were taking an antiarrhythmic drug and 14% (2 participants) a beta-blocker on a continuous basis. Three respondents (21%) were using an antiarrhythmic (propafenone, flecainide or quinidine) to terminate an episode "on demand". Thus 79% of respondents did not take any drugs on a continuous basis in order to manage their LAF and 58% never took any drugs for LAF management. Sixty-four per cent of all respondents got daily sun exposure (lucky sods!) and 71% either had daily sun exposure or supplemented with vitamin D.
Magnesium Intake
Diet
Episode Severity The average duration of episodes was 15.6 hours pre-water and 15.2 hours during the water consumption period. This difference is not statistically significant. Five participants (2 mixed, 3 vagal) experienced a shortening of episodes, 5 (1 adrenergic, 1 mixed, 3 vagal) a lengthening, and 2 saw no change. The decrease in episode duration ranged from 7 to 63% (average 41%) while the increase ranged from 6 to 100% (average 31%). Again it is clear that the effect of the water on episode duration is highly individual. Eight out of 11 respondents (73%) reported that the intensity (feeling of palpitations) of an episode was less after starting on the magnesium/bicarbonate water. The remaining 27% reported no change. This finding suggests that magnesium or bicarbonate somehow helps make the palpitations less noticeable. It is worth noting that the 2 respondents who had not noticed any change in intensity had quite a low total daily magnesium intake (114 mg and 250 mg/day respectively). It is possible that magnesium may reduce episode intensity through its action as a natural calcium channel blocker[1-3]. This action would reduce heart rate and might result in a subjective feeling of lower intensity. There is also some evidence that an increase in serum magnesium level improves left ventricular ejection fraction – at least in heart attack patients[4]. An improved ejection fraction could possibly result in a "calmer environment" due to the fact that the heart would need to contract less forcefully if the ejection fraction was greater. Seven of 12 respondents (58%) felt, on a subjective level, that the magnesium/bicarbonate water had indeed been beneficial in managing their LAF.
Other Benefits
Side Effects
Most side effects were reversible by reducing Mg concentration or discontinuing the water altogether.
Other Observations
Conclusions
An adequate daily magnesium intake is of paramount importance to everyone, but especially to afibbers. Drinking magnesium/bicarbonate water is an excellent way of increasing one's intake of highly bioavailable magnesium. However, whether drinking the water will beneficially affect episode severity can only be determined through individual experimentation.
References
|
The Diet ConnectionI believe there is a strong connection between diet and lone atrial fibrillation, but to my knowledge there is, at present, no medical or scientific evidence that such a connection does indeed exist. Many afibbers have found that dietary changes reduced the frequency and severity of their episodes. Some have found it beneficial to eliminate all dairy and wheat products while others have noticed improvements after eliminating processed foods, trans-fatty acids, aspartame, and MSG (monosodium glutamate) in all its guises. Yet others have found that avoiding potatoes, coffee, peaches, garlic, chocolate, alcohol, and brewer's yeast helped reduce the number of episodes. Caffeine, alcohol and MSG seem to be pretty universal triggers, but it is likely that individual food sensitivities or allergies play a role as far as dairy, wheat, garlic, etc. are concerned. A diet survey was carried out in October 2001 in an attempt to determine if there were any specific dietary components (meats, fruits, grains, etc.) that seemed to correlate with an increased or decreased episode frequency or severity.
A total of 77 afibbers responded to the diet questionnaire. The results were intriguing but raised more questions than they answered. The number of responses simply was not sufficient to draw valid, statistically significant conclusions, especially when it came to looking for diet-related differences between vagal, adrenergic, mixed and permanent afibbers. In retrospect, it is also clear that the questionnaire itself left a lot to be desired (standardized serving sizes, more specific categories, etc.). The questionnaire also enquired about blood type to test the possibility of a link between blood type and LAF or between blood types and optimum diet. Blood type A was most common among vagal afibbers (63%) while type 0 was most common among adrenergic (50%), mixed (58%), and permanent (71%). Is this of significance? I have no idea, but it is intriguing that vagal afibbers (mostly blood type A) are highly unlikely to turn into permanent afibbers (mainly blood type 0). It is difficult to give an overall interpretation of the survey results. All the correlations listed below had a statistical significance of less than 0.05; that is, the outcome has a less than 5% probability of being due to chance – so presumably they should be significant.
There was a trend for adrenergic afibbers who emphasized poultry to spend less time in fibrillation while those emphasizing fruits and vegetables spent more. There were no clear dietary effects on total time spent in fibrillation for vagal and mixed afibbers. Diet did not seem to affect time spent in afib for blood type A, but afibbers with type O spent slightly longer in afib if they also had digestive problems. It would thus seem that pork, poultry, fish, vegetables, fruits and overall carbohydrate consumption could be important factors, but confounding by other variables such as age and drug use cannot be ruled out. It is conceivable that hormones in poultry could affect the autonomic nervous system, as could carbohydrates through the insulin spike caused by high glycemic index foods in particular. This, however, is pure speculation on my part and can only be confirmed or rejected via a much larger, better designed and professionally interpreted study.
EVALUATION OF EFFECTIVE DIETSAt least three afibbers (2 vagal and 1 mixed) have managed to completely eliminate afib episodes for periods of 6 months or more (maximum of 2 years and counting). They all ascribe at least part of their victory over LAF to major dietary changes. Two believe the diet changes were solely responsible for the improvement while the other credits his improvement to a combination of diet changes and complete amalgam (silver) filling removal and elimination of dissimilar metals in the mouth. I obtained detailed 2-day dietary records from the three lucky afibbers and analyzed them for over 60 nutrients and nutrient ratios using the US Department of Agriculture Nutritional Database. The three diets had the following common features:
An obvious question now is, is there any scientific evidence supporting that any of these common dietary traits may eliminate LAF? A relatively high daily intake of water, dietary fiber, vitamins and minerals is clearly a good thing, but none of our LAF survey results have supported the idea that this in itself is likely to affect the frequency or severity of episodes. Could electrolyte (calcium, magnesium, potassium, sodium) levels, glycemic load, protein intake or fish oils influence LAF severity? Let us examine the evidence.
ELECTROLYTE LEVELSThe three effective diets all had a higher than normal content of potassium and magnesium and a higher than normal ratio between potassium and sodium and between magnesium and calcium. That a surplus of the "calming" ions (potassium and magnesium) should be beneficial makes instinctive sense and is supported by the fact that magnesium is known to possess strong antiarrhythmic properties.
Potassium
Magnesium
PROTEINS, CARBOHYDRATES & GLYCEMIC LOADThe average daily protein content of the three diets was 135 grams or 25% of total energy. This is significantly higher than the officially recommended intake of 45-55 grams/day or about 13% of energy. However, it is probably close to the normal protein level in a typical Western diet. Of more significance may be the fact that all three diets provided some protein at each main meal and most snacks. Having protein with every meal ensures that insulin spikes are kept to a minimum and that an adequate amount of glucagon is produced so as to avoid wide hormone fluctuations. This is especially important for afibbers with a tendency to hypoglycemia and also helps lower the demand for cortisol.
Carbohydrates The average carbohydrate intake in the three effective diets was 190 grams (adjusted to a 2000 kcal/day diet) or only about 63% of the recommended amount. In other words, the actual energy intake from carbohydrates was only 38% as compared to the recommended value of 60-65% - clearly a major and highly significant difference. Consuming carbohydrates causes the release of insulin and results in an increase in the level of the stress hormone cortisol[1]. Just like some fats are good and some are bad, so are some carbohydrates good while others are bad. It all depends on the magnitude of the glycemic load they place on the body.
Glycemic Load The term "glycemic index" was first introduced in 1981 as a measure of the rate of absorption and conversion to glucose of various carbohydrate foods. The glycemic index of pure glucose was set to 100, and carbohydrate foods were evaluated against glucose by comparing the rate and extent (area under blood glucose versus time curve) to which 50 grams of the test food was absorbed and converted to glucose with the rate for 50 grams of pure glucose. Recently there has been a trend to use white bread as the standard (glycemic index = 100); under this scheme the glycemic index of pure glucose is 147. Food with a high glycemic index produces a higher peak in blood glucose levels after a meal, and a greater overall blood glucose response during the first 2 hours after consumption, than do foods with a low glycemic index. This higher response is believed to be detrimental to health[4]. The average daily energy-adjusted (to 1700 kcal) glycemic load in a typical Western diet is probably around 105 while a desirable level would be about 70[5]. The average glycemic load of the three effective diets was 72 or, in other words, well below the typical level and close to the desirable level. Whether a low carbohydrate and glycemic load diet will help prevent lone atrial fibrillation obviously needs to be determined in a large clinical trial or epidemiologic study. However, until this is done I see no disadvantage and many possible advantages for afibbers in adhering to a diet similar to that consumed by the 3 "lucky" ex-afibbers. The simplest way to reduce glycemic load is to minimize the intake of high glycemic index foods like potatoes, rice, and white bread.
FISH OILS & FATTY ACID RATIOThe average daily fish oil intake in the three diets during the period when LAF was eliminated was about 2000 mg of EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid) and 2200 mg of DHA (docosahexaenoic acid). This is about 10 times the recommended daily intake, but well within the range of intakes that have proven to be of therapeutic value in diseases and disorders ranging from asthma to schizophrenia. Fish oils are known to have a direct effect on the central nervous system and can block the entry of sodium and calcium ions into vascular smooth muscle cells. This effect, combined with the anti-inflammatory effect, may explain why fish oils help prevent ventricular arrhythmias and sudden cardiac death[6,7]. Researchers at the Massachusetts General Hospital believe that omega-3 fatty acids (fish oils) inhibit the flow of sodium and calcium into the heart cells by actually modifying the ion channels that control the inflow. As a result, a stronger electrical stimulus is required to initiate the process of contraction and the refractory (rest) period between heart beats is markedly prolonged[8]. Australian researchers have found that the composition of the membranes enclosing individual heart cells (myocytes) changes in animals fed fish oils and that this change is beneficial and may explain the antiarrhythmic properties of fish oils[9]. Finally, Canadian researchers have found that DHA, a major component of fish oils, inhibits the inflow of calcium ions into myocytes without affecting their ability to contract[10]. All this research is leading edge and the actual effectiveness of fish oils in the prevention of atrial fibrillation in humans still needs to be proven in clinical trials. Nevertheless, I believe the evidence of possible substantial benefits to afibbers is there and am now supplementing with 1500 mg/day of EPA and 1000 mg/day of DHA. A fish oil intake of this magnitude has proven entirely safe in numerous clinical trials and should pose no problems provided the oils are non-rancid and free of mercury. It is quite possible that the optimum intake of fish oils may vary from person to person and that some afibbers may do better if a small amount of GLA (gamma linolenic acid) is periodically included with the fish oil supplementation[6]. Only experiments on a personal basis will resolve this question.
Omega-6 to Omega-3 Fatty Acid Ratio The average omega-6 to omega-3 fatty acid ratio in the three diets was 2.7:1. This is well below the "danger level" of 20:1 and even well below the currently recommended ratio of 7:1. Thus it would seem that a low omega-6 to omega-3 fatty acid ratio may well be a prominent feature of an effective afib-preventing diet, but obviously more research is required to prove this. The diets were also very low in trans-fatty acids, but again, more research is needed to see if this is important. The main sources of omega-6 fatty acids are vegetable oils such as corn and soy oils that contain a high proportion of linoleic acid. Omega-3 fatty acids are found in flaxseed and walnut oils, marine plankton, and fatty fish. The main component of flaxseed and walnut oils is alpha-linolenic acid (LNA) while the predominant fatty acids found in fatty fish (such as salmon, mackerel, sardines) and fish oils are EPA and DHA, which are the most beneficial and active of these fatty acids. Alpha-linolenic acid (from flaxseed or walnut oils) can be converted to EPA and DHA in the body, but the conversion is quite inefficient especially in older people, diabetics, certain ethnic groups, and some children[11,12,14]. So the best approach to achieving a low omega-6 to omega-3 ratio is to limit the intake of vegetable oils and increase the intake of fish oils.
CONCLUSIONI believe dietary changes could well prove to be the most effective natural way of reducing or completely eliminating afib episodes. Not only have two, and perhaps three, afibbers been able to overcome afib by such changes, but also there are also some very good scientific reasons why this approach should work. I believe all the modifications are important and that they interact to produce the end result. Having protein with every meal, avoiding tyramine-containing foods, reducing carbohydrate intake, and maintaining a low glycemic load would all contribute towards calming the autonomic nervous system and avoiding hypoglycemic episodes. Having an excess of magnesium and potassium in both intra- and extra-cellular fluids would probably help in avoiding the PACs that initiate episodes and a well-hydrated and alkaline environment may help as well. Meanwhile the fish oils would be working quietly in the background to repair the damage caused to individual myocytes by years of afib. Thus, over time, instead of the situation where "afib begets afib" a situation would develop where "sinus rhythm begets sinus rhythm". Eventually the ion channels would be fully repaired and functioning normally. The end result would be no more afib and a return to normal life. Utopia? Perhaps, but at this time I believe it is the best hope for those of us determined to find a non-pharmacologic, non-surgical solution to lone atrial fibrillation. We are all, as someone so aptly put it, "an experiment of one". So what may work wonders for some may not have much effect for others.
References
|
My Afib Journey: Part 2by Hans R. Larsen The year 2001 did not begin on a good note. By the end of March I had endured six episodes and spent 248 hours in fibrillation. Things were looking pretty grim. My diary entry for January 17th reads, "Life really is a pain!" One thing had become increasingly clear to me though and this was that my episodes were all triggered by emotional, mental or physical stress. It was also clear that most of them began between 3 pm and 5 pm. During the first half of the year I continued my search for a supplement combination that would work, but did not come up with anything of obvious value. Whether things would have been worse if I had not supplemented is impossible to say. I also tried out some new exercise regimens and underwent Chinese "scraping" and magnet therapy for several months. It certainly made me feel better, but had no effect on the frequency or duration of my afib episodes. I did find that ginkgo biloba (60 mg twice a day) made me less depressed and as ginkgo is also an effective anticoagulant I decided to continue taking it and have done so to this day. For awhile I took 12.5 mg atenolol at around 2 pm every day in order to protect myself during my vulnerable period between 3 pm and 5 pm. Unfortunately, I was not disciplined enough to take the atenolol every day so it did not have any overall beneficial effect. In July I finally got the break that I had been searching for. I came across an article written by Dr. Andrea Frustaci, a cardiologist at the Catholic University in Rome[1]. Dr. Frustaci had performed biopsies on 12 patients with LAF and found that 8 of them had signs of a current or past inflammation of the heart lining. The inflammation was active in 3 of the 8 patients; they were treated with prednisone and had no episodes during the following 2 years. I corresponded with Dr. Frustaci and learned that it is quite possible that all the 12 LAF patients actually had signs of inflammation, but that the biopsy missed them in 4 of the cases[2]. Six months later independent teams of American and Greek researchers reported that LAF patients had significantly higher levels of the inflammation marker CRP (C-reactive protein) than did people without LAF[3,4]. After a careful study of Dr. Frustaci's work I decided to assume that I probably had an inflammation of the heart lining and set out to devise a scheme to eradicate it. In retrospect, I probably should have had a CRP test done before I began, but at the time it was not readily available and my physician was not familiar with it. My approach to eliminating LAF was two-pronged – using dietary modifications and lifestyle changes to avoid "feeding" and constantly aggravating the inflammation and using natural supplements to dampen and heal the inflammation. I am a type O blood type so I decided to follow Dr. Peter D'Adamo's diet for type O. The main features are total avoidance of all wheat and gluten-containing products, dairy products (except butter), kidney beans, lentils, peanuts, potatoes, eggplant, peppers, and a few other foods. Grains and cereals should be consumed in moderation (cornflakes, corn, oat bran, and shredded wheat should be avoided). The diet emphasizes protein in the form of lean meat, fish, and poultry and avoids pork, bacon, and ham. Other research has shown that a high intake of omega-6 fatty acids promotes inflammation. So I severely cut back on these types of fats (found in margarines and cooking oils) and increased my intake of omega-3 fatty acids (found in fatty fish and flax oil). I began modifying my lifestyle quite a few years ago and continued with these changes. I avoid alcohol and caffeine and try to control both my emotional and physical stress levels. I took the following supplements daily for the purpose of dampening and eventually eliminating inflammation. These were in addition to my regular supplements. 1 hour before breakfast - Moducare 2 capsules[a]
With breakfast -
Mid-morning (on empty stomach) -
1 hour before lunch - Moducare 2 capsules
With lunch -
Mid-afternoon (on empty stomach) –
1 hour before dinner - Moducare 2 capsules
With dinner -
Before bed - Protec probiotic 2 capsules[e]
NOTES:
I began my anti-inflammation protocol on August 4th. I found it somewhat hard to completely eliminate all wheat and dairy products (except for butter), but eventually managed to do so once my wife found a great recipe for cookies made with quinoa flour! I now believe this was a very important first step. I also moderated my exercise program and increased my protein intake as per the blood type O diet. I had no problems taking the Moducare capsules on an empty stomach, but found the curcumin/bromelain combination to be quite irritating to the stomach so I switched to taking them with meals. I had originally included the herb Boswellia in my program, but found it gave me a headache so I discontinued it after 2 days. Throughout the protocol I measured my pulse rate, number of ectopic beats over a 5-minute period, heart rate variability, and autonomic nervous system balance daily using a fingertip pulse monitor and software program (Freeze Framer) developed by the Heart Math Institute in California. On August 3rd I counted 15 ectopic beats (over 5 minutes) and my maximum power spectrum value was 156 milliseconds squared/Hertz – normal is about 8 to 30. So in other words, my heart's performance was rather chaotic. A month later on September 3rd things had changed quite remarkably. I recorded no ectopic beats and the maximum power spectrum value had decreased to 12. I also felt great, but the balance between the sympathetic (adrenergic) and parasympathetic branches was still a bit unusual. On September 19th I reduced my Moducare intake to one capsule three times a day instead of the two capsules three times a day I had been on since I began the protocol. Coincidence or not, I don't know, but early in the morning on September 21st I experienced my first LAF episode in 2 months. All veteran afibbers will know what a huge disappointment that was! I carried on with the protocol continuing to take three Moducare capsules a day, but reducing the curcumin/bromelain intake to just once a day (at lunch). I then went 5 weeks without an episode. During this time I was regularly clocking zero PACs and PVCs, my maximum power spectrum value was around 28 and my autonomic nervous system balance was normal. On November 29th I decided to discontinue the anti-inflammatory protocol for three reasons:
Well, on December 4th I got my answer in the form of a 60-hour episode! This was followed by a 25-hour one on December 10th. So I now had the answer to what would happen if I went off the protocol! In the meantime, I had heard from several afibbers who have found MSM (methyl sulfonyl methane) helpful. MSM has strong anti-inflammatory properties and is a cholinesterase inhibitor meaning that it enhances parasympathetic activity – just the ticket for adrenergic afibbers, but possibly not so great for vagal ones. MSM also crosses the blood/brain barrier and is reputed to bind to mercury and help excrete it. Sounded like a winner, so I decided to add 1000 mg of MSM (taken with breakfast) to the 3 capsules of Moducare (taken ½ hour before main meals). I had also come across some very interesting information on American ginseng (Panax quinquefolius). Apparently American ginseng not only helps keep blood sugar levels under control, it also partially blocks sodium channels. This effect is similar to that of antiarrhythmics such as flecainide (Tambocor) and propafenone (Rythmol). Seemed like a promising candidate for the protocol so I decided to take 500 mg with breakfast. I should point out that only American ginseng has the above effects – Korean, Siberian and Chinese ginseng do not. My personal anti-inflammatory protocol now consisted of 3 Moducare capsules per day plus 1000 mg of MSM and 500 mg of American ginseng. I want to emphasize that I have the adrenergic form of LAF and MSM may not be good for the vagal kind. I began the new protocol on December 15th and within 4 days it had completely eliminated ectopic beats and produced a very satisfactory HRV graph on the Freeze Framer. I had found no evidence that any of the components of the protocol have any long-term detrimental effects. The Holiday Season also gave me the opportunity to confirm that I do indeed have a serious reaction to wheat- containing foods. I normally avoid them, but with all the special cakes and cookies on offer during the holidays I confess I did "slip". Invariably I would end up with numerous ectopic beats about 12 hours later. So wheat in all its many forms is definitely no good for me. Early in 2002 I received the results of my CRP test. The result was normal indicating that I did not suffer from an inflammation. During the first 2 months of the new year I had 5 afib episodes. The anti-inflammation protocol was obviously not working any longer and since I now knew for certain that I did not have an inflammation I decided to discontinue it altogether. During the next few months I experimented with an herbal detoxification program, Dr. Andrew Weil's relaxed breathing program, chiropractic and osteopathic manipulation, and healing touch massage. All to no avail. To add insult to injury I was diagnosed with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) in March. Since this was quite painful and uncomfortable I had to divert my attention from finding a solution to LAF to finding a solution to IBS. Fortunately, this proved to be a lot easier. Avoiding certain foods, taking Metamucil (not the aspartame- containing version) before meals, dealing with the pain by taking enteric-coated peppermint oil capsules and faithfully listening every day to a self-hypnosis tape by Mahoney[5] essentially cured me of the IBS in a little under 4 months. I no longer need the Metamucil or the peppermint oil, but still listen to the tape as it is very relaxing. I wish finding a cure for LAF was this easy! In July I began investigating the connection between cortisol/DHEA levels and afib episodes. I had my cortisol and DHEA levels measured (in saliva) and while my cortisol level was fairly normal, although low at around 4 pm, my DHEA level was way off the lower end of the scale. Unfortunately, since I live in Canada where DHEA is a banned substance and importation exposes one to the risk of obtaining a criminal record there is not much I can do about this aspect of my research findings. However, for those of you who live in the US the DHEA connection would definitely be worth looking into. I am now trying to model my diet on that of the three "lucky ones" and hope that this will be the answer. Time will tell. At least this approach has renewed my hope and, as all fibbers know, hope is one of the most important ingredients in coping with afib.
References
|
|
The AFIB REPORT is published monthly by Hans R. Larsen MSc ChE 1320 Point Street Victoria, BC, Canada V8S 1A5 Phone: (250) 384-2524 E-mail: [email protected] URL: http://www.afibbers.org Copyright © 2003 by Hans R. Larsen The AFIB REPORT does not provide medical advice. Do not attempt self- diagnosis or self-medication based on our reports. Please consult your health-care provider if you wish to follow up on the information presented. |